Coming on the heels of the National Toxicology Program's
(NTP) recent report on the safety of bispheonl A (BPA), a type of polycarbonate
plastic that is commonly used in food and drink packaging, a new study points to
additional, previously unrecognized health concerns. Together, these reports create
a body of information, while not proving causality, certainly raises the level of
concern regarding human exposure to this ubiquitous plastic.
What are the health concerns related to BPA? Recently, the National
Toxicology Program
(NTP) released a report summarizing the potential health risks associated with BPA.
There are at least two ways of interpreting this report. On one hand, the report
reaffirmed concerns reported this spring that that BPA may have an effect on mammary
glands and maturation of females during early puberty, as well as indicating several
newer, potential health risks. On the other hand, the level of concern was relatively
low, with none of the issues reaching a level higher than "some concern" on a 5-point
scale with "some concern" representing the mid-point. The program concluded that
more research is needed to understand exactly how these findings relate to human
health and development. Specifically, the NTP reported:
- Some concern for the effect
of BPA on the brain, behavior, and prostate gland in fetuses, infants, and children.
- Minimal concern for effects of BPA on the mammary gland and an earlier age for
puberty for females in fetuses, infants, and children.
- Negligible concern for
fetal or neonatal death, birth defects, or reduced birth weight and growth in babies
born to women exposed to bisphenol A during pregnancy.
- Negligible concern that
exposure to bisphenol A will cause reproductive effects in non-occupationally exposed
adults and minimal concern for workers exposed to higher levels in occupational
settings.
Perhaps even more bothersome, however, is a study published this week
in the Journal of the American Medical Association that raised new concerns about
the health effects of BPA. This study found that those with the highest levels of
BPA in their urine had nearly three times the risk of heart disease and more than
twice the risk of diabetes as those who had the lowest levels.
Where is BPA found?
BPA is used in a number of consumer goods, including the lining of metal cans and
plastic beverage containers. It is also used to make infant bottles, compact discs,
impact-resistant safety equipment, and medical devices. Epoxy resins are used as
lacquers to coat metal products such as food cans, bottle tops, and water supply
pipes. Some dental sealants and composites may also contain BPA.
How does BPA get
into the body? The primary way that most people are exposed to BPA is through the
diet. BPA can leach into food from the protective internal epoxy resin coatings
of canned foods and from consumer products such as polycarbonate tableware, food
storage containers, water bottles, and baby bottles. A study conducted by the Centers
for Disease Control in 2003-2004 found detectable levels of BPA in 93% of people
six years and older that they studied. In spite of this widespread exposure, no
one has confirmed its safety in humans.
Does this mean that BPA will be banned from
use? Not yet. At this time, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) continues
to consider the level of exposure to BPA in humans too low to pose a health risk.
Even the AMA study, while noting that those with elevated BPA levels were more likely
to have heart disease or diabetes, did not prove that BPA caused those diseases.
It is conceivable that the individuals with heart disease or diabetes had a generally
unhealthy lifestyle that included eating high fat foods contained in cans and drinking
sugared soft drinks in polycarbonate containers. In other words, their exposure
to BPA was higher than average, but they may have developed the illnesses anyway.
What can I do to limit my exposure to BPA?
If you are convinced that BPA poses a
significant health risk, there are ways that you can reduce your or your family's
exposure:
- Avoid products in polycarbonate containers that contain BPA. These usually
have a recycling symbol with the number 7 on them (the #7 category also includes
and other types of plastic that
do not necessarily contain BPA).
- Instead, opt
for containers made of glass, carboard, or stainless steel.
- Don't micowave or
heat food containers containing polycarbonate.
- Use baby bottles that do not contain
BPA (Born Free, Green to Grow, and ThinkBaby make BPA-free plastic baby bottles).
Clearly, more study is needed to help resolve the issue. In the meantime, some states
are considering restricting the use of BPA and certain retailers including Wal-Mart
and Babies "R" Us are voluntarily backing away from selling baby bottles containing
BPA. Even the company that manufactures the popular Nalgene brand of water containers
have decided to phase out the use of BPA in their products. An advisory panel to
the FDA is reviewing existing information regarding the health effects of BPA and
will be reporting to the FDA in the near future. Perhaps new guidelines regarding
human exposure to BPA or the use of BPA in food or beverage containers will be forthcoming.
I'll stay tuned to this issue and report new developments in future Health Tips.
|